What happens to a fish's swim bladder under the ice
A 2013 study from Norway: echo sounders watched sprat all winter.
Why this matters to anglers
Many fish have an "open" swim bladder: it is connected to the gut by a duct. Among the fish anglers usually catch, these include cyprinids (roach, bream, crucian carp, carp), pike and salmonids, while perch and zander have a closed bladder. This is general fish anatomy, not a finding of this study.
A popular explanation on fishing websites goes: "when the pressure jumps, the fish cannot release air from its swim bladder quickly, so it stops feeding". This study shows how a fish with an open bladder actually handles gas — without ice and under the ice.
About the study
- Original
- Solberg I., Kaartvedt S. Surfacing behavior and gas release of the physostome sprat (Sprattus sprattus) in ice-free and ice-covered waters. Marine Biology, 2014, vol. 161, pp. 285–296 (online in 2013).
- DOI
- 10.1007/s00227-013-2334-1
- Language
- English.
- Access
- open, full text in PubMed Central. Licence CC BY.
In short
In a 150 m deep fjord near Oslo, three upward-facing echo sounders were deployed. All through the winter of 2009/2010 they recorded sprat rising to the surface and gas bubbles coming out of the fish. The fjord froze on 6–8 January and the ice melted in early April. This made it possible to compare the same fish before the ice, under the ice and after it.
How it was studied
- Where
- Bunnefjorden, the innermost part of the Oslofjord, Norway. Below 80 m the water has almost no oxygen.
- When
- 11 November 2009 – 12 April 2010 (16 years ago).
- How
- echo sounders on the bottom and on buoys at 80 and 30 m recorded fish and gas bubbles around the clock;
- test trawls (33 hauls) confirmed the fish were sprat: 7,345 sprat were caught;
- echo strength was used to judge how much gas was in the bladder (the gas in the bladder produces about 90% of a fish's echo).
- Sprat
- a small marine fish of the herring family.
Facts for anglers
- Without ice, sprat rise to the surface only at night and then release gas
- A fish with an open bladder releases gas dozens of times a day
- Under the ice, fish rise to the ice again and again, as if looking for air
- Under the ice there is less gas in the bladder
- Under the ice, fish swim up and down more slowly
- After the fjord froze there were fewer sprat, but some overwintered
- Surfacing was not linked to cloud cover or the phase of the moon
1Without ice, sprat rise to the surface only at night and then release gas
Sprat came to the surface only in the dark, never during the day. On average this was about 3.5 times per fish per day. A few hours after surfacing, gas bubbles came out of the fish. The authors conclude that sprat gulp air at the surface.
Quote“There were no records of surfacing sprat during daytime”
A fish with an open bladder manages how full it is every day. This is a normal part of its life, not a rare event.
2A fish with an open bladder releases gas dozens of times a day
Before the ice formed, sprat released gas on average 72 times per fish per day, and 35 times after the ice melted. That is an order of magnitude more often than they came to the surface.
Quote“the rate of gas release was an order of magnitude higher than the rate of surfacing”
The claim that "a fish cannot quickly release air from its swim bladder" does not apply to a fish with an open bladder — it lets gas out constantly and easily. Its poor feeding cannot be blamed on "the bladder".
3Under the ice, fish rise to the ice again and again, as if looking for air
After the fjord froze, there were not fewer trips to the surface but more: about 12.5 per fish per day on average over three months, and about 24 in one week of January. Fish came up under the ice, dived and rose again. Nothing like this happened without ice.
Quote“Several of the fish just under the ice repeatedly ascended to the surface before descending”
For a fish with an open bladder, ice is an obstacle it has to cope with.
4Under the ice there is less gas in the bladder
Under the ice, gas came out only about twice per fish per day — dozens of times less often than before the ice. The echo from the fish became weaker, so there was less gas in the bladder. The authors conclude that the sprat could hardly refill their bladders with air under the ice.
Quote“Gas release was strongly reduced when the fjord was ice covered”
Under the ice a fish with an open bladder has less gas and finds it harder to hold its depth in midwater. The study did not check how this affects feeding.
5Under the ice, fish swim up and down more slowly
Without ice, sprat swam down from the surface at about 28 cm/s; under the ice, at about 11 cm/s.
The authors' explanation: with a full bladder the fish is buoyant and has to dive hard. Under the ice there is no air, and no such effort is needed.
Quote“Vertical swimming associated with surface events was considerably slower when the fjord was ice covered”
How much gas is in the bladder shows even in the way a fish moves.
6After the fjord froze there were fewer sprat, but some overwintered
According to the echo sounders, there were at least three times fewer fish in the fjord in January–March than in November. But some of the sprat survived the winter under the ice.
Quote“The abundance of sprat generally declined after the fjord froze over”
Where the fish went — whether they left or died — the study did not establish. So this cannot be put down to the bladder.
7Surfacing was not linked to cloud cover or the phase of the moon
How often sprat came to the surface did not depend on cloud cover or on the phase of the moon.
Quote“No consistent pattern between frequency of surfacing events and cloud index or moon phase was evident”
This is about sprat surfacing, not about feeding. But it is one more observation in which the moon and clouds did not control fish behaviour.
Limits
- Sprat is a marine fish. It belongs to the herring family and is not a freshwater species. Citing earlier work, the authors write that most fish with an open bladder have no organ that produces gas and apparently fill their bladder with air from the surface.
- From another study, not this one: in cyprinids, gas can enter the bladder from the blood. This was shown in experiments on goldfish (Wittenberg, 1958, DOI). Hence our assumption: cyprinids probably depend on the ice less than sprat do. Whether anyone has tested this under the ice, we do not know.
- One place and one winter: a single fjord, sea water, almost no oxygen below 80 m.
- "Looking for air" is the authors' interpretation. They measured surfacing, bubbles and echo strength, not the gas in the bladder directly.
Takeaways for anglers
- A fish with an open bladder releases gas constantly. The explanation "the fish cannot release air, so it will not feed" does not apply to it.
- Under the ice it is harder for a fish with an open bladder to keep its bladder full. Whether this affects feeding, the study did not check.
- In this study, clouds and the moon did not influence fish behaviour.
Related breakdowns
How we checked
We read the full text (PubMed Central) in full on 18 November 2026. The quotes were checked word for word against the original. The "open this place in the study" link scrolls the original to the right sentence and highlights it.