Roach and perch on a mormyshka through the ice: catch rates and survival after release
A 2019 study from Poland.
About the study
- Original
- Czarkowski T. K., Kapusta A. Catch-and-Release Ice Fishing with a Mormyshka for Roach (Rutilus rutilus) and European Perch (Perca fluviatilis). Croatian Journal of Fisheries, 2019, vol. 77, pp. 235–242.
- DOI
- 10.2478/cjf-2019-0017
- Language
- English.
- Access
- open, PDF on the journal's website. Licence CC BY-NC-ND: quoting is allowed, translating the whole paper is not.
In short
An experienced angler spent three weeks ice fishing for roach and perch on two Polish lakes, using a mormyshka (a small weighted ice jig) baited with bloodworm and maggots. The researchers recorded everything: how many fish were caught per hour, where each fish was hooked, how many seconds it took to unhook it and whether it survived in a cage under the ice. All the mormyshkas had the same shape, some with a barb and some without, so the two could be compared.
How it was studied
- Where
- two lakes in the Masurian Lake District, north-eastern Poland — Sarąg (1.8 km²) and Serwent (2.4 km²). Both lakes are rich in food.
- When
- 25 January – 16 February 2017 (9 years ago).
- Tackle
- a 30 cm ice rod, 0.09 mm line and a bite indicator made from a thin strip of plastic;
- tungsten mormyshkas of the same shape, with and without a barb;
- baited with bloodworm (midge larvae) and maggots;
- fished near the bottom at 7.1–7.3 m through 12 cm holes.
- How many fish
- 288 — 157 perch and 131 roach. The fish were small: perch averaged 15.1 cm, roach 15.5 cm.
- Survival
- the fish were kept for 4 hours in cages under the ice to see whether they swam normally.
Facts for anglers
- About 16 roach and 14 perch were caught per hour
- The barbless mormyshka caught just as well
- Almost all fish were hooked in the upper jaw; perch were deep-hooked almost three times as often as roach
- Without a barb, roach were unhooked almost three times faster; for perch the difference was smaller
- Not a single roach died; two of 157 perch did
- Perch brought up from 7 metres can suffer barotrauma; it was not recorded in roach
1About 16 roach and 14 perch were caught per hour
The angler caught an average of 16.4 roach and 13.6 perch per hour.
For comparison, the authors cite other studies:
- roach on a float — 1.9 fish per hour in autumn and 8.7 in early spring;
- perch in summer — no more than 2 fish per hour, on both artificial and natural bait;
- perch through the ice with other methods — 2.6 to 24.7 fish per hour, 11.9 on average. This is close to the result of this study.
These are different waters, seasons and tackle, so the comparison is rough.
Quote“Average CPUE for roach was 16.4 fish/h, and for European perch it was 13.6 fish/h”
A mormyshka fished near the bottom with bloodworm or maggots is a very effective way to catch small roach and perch through the ice, once you have found a shoal.
2The barbless mormyshka caught just as well
For neither roach nor perch did the authors find a difference in catch between the barbed and the barbless mormyshka.
Of the fish hooked, the share landed was:
- roach — 90–92% with either mormyshka;
- perch — 83% barbed and 88% barbless.
The authors' explanation: under the ice a fish is brought up quickly and vertically, the line never goes slack, and the barb has no work to do in holding the hook.
Quote“the hook type was inconsequential and had no significant impact on the level or efficiency of the catches”
You can safely use a barbless mormyshka (or one with the barb crushed): you will not lose more fish, whether roach or perch.
3Almost all fish were hooked in the upper jaw; perch were deep-hooked almost three times as often as roach
More than 90% of roach and more than 80% of perch were hooked in the upper jaw.
Deep-hooked:
- perch — about 8%;
- roach — about 3%.
Only perch swallowed the mormyshka into the oesophagus, and rarely. Roach never did.
The authors' explanation: the point of a mormyshka hook faces upwards and sits almost horizontal to the line, so it lands in the upper jaw.
Quote“over 90% of the roach and over 80% of the perch were hooked in the upper jaw”
Hooking with a mormyshka is gentle on both species. Deep hooking is rare, though more common in perch.
4Without a barb, roach were unhooked almost three times faster; for perch the difference was smaller
On average, fish were unhooked in 1.8 seconds.
- Roach took 2.5 seconds to unhook from a barbed mormyshka and 0.9 seconds from a barbless one.
- Perch took 2.3 and 1.6 seconds. The authors do not consider this difference significant.
The authors' explanation: cyprinids have fleshy, flexible lips, and the barb gets stuck in them. A perch's mouth is built differently.
Quote“Hook removal from roach captured on barbed mormyshka took almost three times longer than the barbless mormyshka”
Without a barb you get back to the hole faster, especially with roach. On an active shoal that means extra bites per session.
5Not a single roach died; two of 157 perch did
Not a single roach died — neither immediately nor within 4 hours in a cage under the ice.
Two of the 157 perch died, and both had been caught on a barbed mormyshka. According to the authors, one of them had swallowed the bait deeply.
Injuries were rare:
- slight tears to the upper jaw — in 5.1% of perch and 4.6% of roach;
- bleeding — in one perch;
- there were more injuries with barbed hooks than with barbless ones: 6.9% versus 2.8%.
The authors point out that most anglers are convinced it is pointless to release fish caught in winter, because they will die anyway. In their view, the study shows that this need not be so.
Quote“Nor was short-term mortality observed after holding roach for 4 h in cages; however, in the case of European perch this type of mortality occurred in just two individuals”
Small roach and perch caught on a mormyshka can be released — their chances of survival are good.
6Perch brought up from 7 metres can suffer barotrauma; it was not recorded in roach
Four perch brought up from about 7 m showed signs of barotrauma: they struggled to swim down in the cage. This passed within 4 hours. The authors report no such cases in roach.
Quote“barotrauma was confirmed in four European perch”
A perch has a closed swim bladder and cannot quickly release gas as it is brought up. A roach's swim bladder is connected to the gut by a duct, so it can let excess gas out. That is why a perch released after being brought up from depth may stay near the surface for a while, and a roach is less likely to.
Limits
- Narrow conditions. One angler, two lakes, three weeks, a depth of about 7 m.
- Small fish. The fish were around 15 cm. Results may differ for larger roach and perch.
- Short observation. Survival was checked for only 4 hours. What happened after a day is unknown. The authors themselves note that mortality in the first hours can underestimate total mortality.
- The comparison with other methods is rough: it comes from other studies on other waters.
- Inconsistencies within the paper:
- perch caught per hour — 13.6 in the Results and 13.1 in the Discussion;
- the Discussion says no roach were deep-hooked, while the table shows about 3% of roach hooked in the palate, which counts as deep hooking by the authors' own method;
- the two perch deaths are described as deaths within 4 hours in the cage in the Results, but as deaths immediately after capture in the Discussion.
Takeaways for anglers
- A mormyshka fished near the bottom with bloodworm or maggots is one of the most effective ways to catch small roach and perch through the ice.
- A barbless mormyshka catches just as well. Roach are unhooked almost three times faster, perch a little faster.
- Small roach and perch caught on a mormyshka can be released: in the study, 2 of 157 perch and not a single roach died.
- A perch brought up from 7 metres may not swim down straight away. In the study this passed within 4 hours.
Related breakdowns
How we checked
We read the full text (PDF) in full on 18 November 2026. The quotes were checked word for word against the original. The page links open the PDF where each fact is stated.