What affects the catch: 13 years of records of every fishing trip on one lake

A 2021 study from the USA: weather, pressure, the moon — or the angler.

Русская версия

About the study

Original
Shaw S. L., Renik K. M., Sass G. G. Angler and environmental influences on walleye Sander vitreus and muskellunge Esox masquinongy angler catch in Escanaba Lake, Wisconsin 2003–2015. PLoS ONE, 2021, vol. 16, no. 10, e0257882.
DOI
10.1371/journal.pone.0257882
Language
English.
Access
open, full text on the journal's website. Licence CC BY.

In short

On Escanaba Lake, a research lake in the USA, every angler must take a free permit and, after fishing, report what they used, whether they had a guide and how much they caught. The researchers took 13 years of these records and compared what had a bigger effect on the catch of two predators: what the angler did, or the weather, light, the moon and pressure.

The authors' answer: the angler matters most (the guide and the bait). Weather and the moon also had an effect, but a very small one. Pressure changes carried little weight in the analysis.

2003–2015records of every fishing trip on one lake
2,005trips targeting walleye
2,771trips targeting muskellunge
1.32 → 0.95walleye per hour on live bait: as recorded and adjusted for other factors

How it was studied

Where
Escanaba Lake, Wisconsin, USA. Area 119 ha, mean depth 4.3 m.
When
2003–2015 (11 years ago), open water only (roughly from late April to late October). Night fishing is banned on the lake, so all trips took place in daylight and at dawn and dusk.
Fish
  • walleye — a North American species, a close relative of the European zander: 2,005 trips;
  • muskellunge — a large North American pike: 2,771 trips.
What was compared
  • the angler: whether there was a guide, live or artificial bait, how many anglers were on the lake that day, what share of the fish had already been caught and released that season;
  • the weather: change in pressure over the day, precipitation, wind, solar radiation (cloud cover together with seasonal and daily changes in sunlight), air temperature, time of day;
  • the moon: phase and position (overhead or "underfoot").
Where the lake is
Source: coordinates from the paper (46°03′49″ N, 89°35′12″ W); map © OpenStreetMap contributors

Facts for anglers

  1. The angler turned out to matter most
  2. Pressure changes and precipitation hardly affected the catch
  3. Weather and the moon shift the odds only slightly
  4. Walleye were caught better in low light; for muskellunge the picture is contradictory
  5. The moon had an effect, but not through its light
  6. Live bait for walleye produced more fish, but less than it seems
  7. The more fish already caught that season, the worse they bite

1The angler turned out to matter most

According to the authors' calculations, the most important factors were the guide and the bait, not the weather: they were in all the best models. For walleye, the share of fish already caught that season also mattered.

A caveat on the size of the effect:

  • for walleye, the guide and the bait changed the catch moderately or slightly, while weather and the moon changed it only a little;
  • for muskellunge, according to the authors, every factor, including the guide and the bait, had a very weak effect.
Where to check in the study "Abstract"; "Results", "Walleye — Trip success", Table 1 — open this place in the study.
Quote

“Fishing trip success and catch rates for both species were most strongly influenced by angler-related variables”

What it means for anglers

Knowing the water and using the right bait gives you more than guessing the weather.

2Pressure changes and precipitation hardly affected the catch

The researchers specifically included the change in pressure over the day and precipitation — the main signs of a weather front. In no analysis did these factors carry much weight. Wind, light and air temperature carried more weight, but the authors rate their effect as very small too.

Where to check in the study "Discussion", the paragraph on weather and fronts — open this place in the study.
Quote

“large changes in barometric pressure and precipitation are associated with frontal weather and yet these environmental factors were not highly weighted in any analysis”

What it means for anglers

The rule "pressure drops, no bites" did not hold up across 13 years of records. A barometer is no reason to stay at home.

3Weather and the moon shift the odds only slightly

Light, the moon, wind and temperature did affect the catch, but, by the authors' own standards, very weakly. For walleye, more weakly than the guide and the bait; for muskellunge, every factor was very weak.

Where to check in the study "Results", "Walleye — Trip success", Table 1; "Muskellunge — Trip success", Table 2 — open this place in the study.
Quote

“all of these variables had very small effect sizes”

What it means for anglers

The weather shifts your chances a little; it does not decide how the trip goes.

4Walleye were caught better in low light; for muskellunge the picture is contradictory

Walleye were caught more often, and in greater numbers, on overcast days and at dawn and dusk. The authors' explanation: walleye eyes are adapted to low light.

On muskellunge, the paper contradicts itself:

  • the Discussion says the chance of catching one also rose in low light;
  • the Abstract says light had a positive effect on muskellunge;
  • among successful trips, muskellunge catch rates were higher in the day and evening than in the morning.

Muskellunge do not have the low-light adaptation that walleye have, and the authors suggest the cause may be the activity of their prey rather than the light.

Where to check in the study "Abstract"; "Discussion", the paragraph on light — open this place in the study.
Quote

“Walleye and muskellunge trip success and CPUE for successful walleye trips on Escanaba Lake generally increased as light conditions decreased”

What it means for anglers

Time of day and cloud cover matter, but differently for each species. There is no single "overcast means bites" rule for all fish.

5The moon had an effect, but not through its light

The phase of the moon and its position — overhead or "underfoot" — were linked to the catch. But nobody fishes the lake at night, so moonlight is not the cause. The authors do not know why. They suggest gravity or magnetic changes but did not test this.

Where to check in the study "Discussion", the paragraph on the moon — open this place in the study.
Quote

“there is no legal fishing allowed at night, so in this case lunar illumination would not have a direct effect on angling trip success”

What it means for anglers

There is a link with the moon, but it is weak and its mechanism is unknown. This study gives no grounds for planning your fishing by a lunar calendar.

6Live bait for walleye produced more fish, but less than it seems

Nearly all walleye trips (92.4%) used live bait. Among anglers who caught any walleye, live bait gave 1.32 walleye per hour and artificial bait 0.68. But after adjusting for the guide, time, weather and other factors, the gap narrowed to 0.95 versus 0.84. For muskellunge, live bait gave a slightly better chance of catching at least one, while artificial lures gave more fish to those who caught any.

Walleye per hour for anglers who caught at least one
Live baitArtificial
As recorded
1.32
0.68
Adjusted for guide, time, weather and other factors
0.95
0.84
Source: the Results section, "Walleye — Catch rate", and Figure 6 of the study
Where to check in the study "Results", "Walleye — Catch rate", Figure 6; "Muskellunge — Catch rate" — open this place in the study.
Quote

“Walleye CPUE for successful trips was significantly higher when using live bait relative to artificial bait only”

What it means for anglers

Bait matters, but a simple comparison of catches "by eye" overstates its role: once other factors were accounted for, the difference became much smaller. Why — this is our assumption, not something in the paper: perhaps more experienced anglers use live bait more often.

7The more fish already caught that season, the worse they bite

According to the authors' calculation, the larger the share of the lake's walleye already caught and released that season, the lower the catch rate. Early in the season — 0.91 walleye per hour. Once anglers had caught about one and a half times the population (many fish were caught more than once) — 0.74.

The authors suggest the fish may have learned to avoid lures.

Caveats:

  • in the raw records the catch stayed roughly level until about 100% of the population had been caught, and only then fell;
  • in trip success (whether you caught any at all), the decline is not always visible — the authors say so themselves.
Walleye per hour for successful trips
the authors' estimate; share — how much of the lake's walleye had already been caught and released that season
Early in the season, almost none caught
0.91
About 150% of the population caught
0.74
Source: the Results section, "Walleye — Catch rate", of the study
Where to check in the study "Results", "Walleye — Catch rate"; "Discussion", second paragraph — open this place in the study.
Quote

“The proportion of the walleye population captured had a negative effect on CPUE of successful trips”

What it means for anglers (our explanation)

Fish are warier where they are fished hard. This has not been tested for non-predatory fish or ice fishing, but it explains why a crowded swim fishes worse than an untouched one.

Limits

  • Predators and open water. Walleye and muskellunge, one lake in the USA, fishing only in daylight and at dawn and dusk. The findings apply to non-predatory fish, such as roach and bream, and to ice fishing only as a rough guide.
  • Crude pressure data. Pressure was measured twice a day, and the change over the day was used. Short jumps in the hours before a front may not have been captured.
  • Incomplete data. The authors did not consider how weather factors act together, and did not know where on the lake each angler fished.
  • An observation, not an experiment. For example, experienced anglers go out at dawn and dusk more often — and this can look like "an effect of time of day". The authors acknowledge this themselves.

Takeaways for anglers

  • Do not cancel a trip because of the barometer: across 13 years of records, pressure changes hardly affected the catch.
  • Invest in what you control: the swim, the bait, knowledge of the water.
  • Light and time of day matter, but modestly and differently for different fish. The moon has a weak effect, and why is unknown.

Related breakdowns

How we checked

We read the full text (PubMed Central, PMC8483380) on 18 November 2026: abstract, methods, results, discussion. The quotes were checked word for word against the original. The "open this place in the study" link goes to the journal's website, scrolls to the right sentence and highlights it.